Voice chat NEWHow to PlayCasesPricingBlogFAQPLAY FREE →
Secret Santa at HollybrookCOLD CASE
File #VT-2023-1224 Hollybrook House · Stowe, Vermont · December 2023
FILE REOPENEDMEDIUM

Secret Santa at Hollybrook

FROM THE CASE FILE
Every Christmas Eve the Pembertons drew names, bought one gift each and swore never to tell. At 9:35 Walter Pemberton unwrapped a gold box of cherry cordials and laughed: 'Nobody's confessing?' Nobody did. By midnight he was dead.
DURATION25–35 MIN
SUSPECTS4
EXHIBITS10

Each detective gets half the evidence. Talk it through and name the killer.

NEW Play live on two devices — with built-in voice chat

The suspects

6'5'4'3'2'1'GP · 4423NO. 1
Gideon PembertonAge 41 · Son, Chief Operating Officer

Motive: At dinner Walter told him Pemberton Toys would be sold, not handed down

6'5'4'3'2'1'VH · 4107NO. 2
Vivian HaleAge 54 · Fiancée, Retired Cardiac Nurse

Motive: Walter had put off the wedding — and the new will — until after the sale

6'5'4'3'2'1'DK · 8673NO. 3
Desmond KerrAge 47 · Finance Director & Godson

Motive: Walter had asked him to bring the toy-drive ledgers on December 26

6'5'4'3'2'1'RO · 7191NO. 4
Ruth OkaforAge 63 · Head Toy Designer, 31 Years

Motive: The sale took the rights to every toy she had ever designed

Case file excerptFile #VT-2023-1224
VICTIM
Walter Pemberton, 71 — founder, Pemberton Toys
FOUND
December 24, 2023, 10:55 PM — collapsed in his armchair by the fire
LOCATION
Living room, Hollybrook House, Stowe, Vermont
INITIAL RULING
Cardiac arrest — known heart condition
CLASSIFIED

Other open cases